Evaluations Based on Evidence Not Opinion

Make every rating clear and based on the full picture.

RefynED helps schools see the full picture behind every evaluation so ratings are based on evidence, not opinion, with clarity early enough to act.

Calibration is not about scoring the same. It is about seeing the same evidence clearly.

What's at Risk

Schools make important decisions about teachers with incomplete evidence

When evaluations affect pay, funding, and retention, that matters. When the evidence is thin or inconsistent, those decisions are exposed.

  • Different evaluators

    Evaluators score identically performing teachers differently creating inconsistency districts can't defend.
  • Not enough evidence

    Ratings are submitted without sufficient evidence tied to the rubric to support the decision.
  • Little visibility before it's final

    Leaders can't see what's missing until everything is already submitted — too late to fix.

THE REAL ISSUE

Rubrics do not create an accurate picture on their own

Schools already have rubrics. What they don't always have is a clear picture of whether a rating is actually supported. Evidence is often thin, shows up late, and varies from one evaluator to another. That is how weak evaluations happen.

Leaders are expected to stand behind these decisions but many still cannot see what is missing, what does not line up, or where there is risk before ratings are finalized

WHY NOW

The stakes have changed

  • The stakes have changed

    Every rating shows what supports it, what is missing, and what needs attention before it is finalized.
  • Funding is on the line

    Grant programs and federal requirements increasingly hinge on defensible evaluation data.
  • Retention depends on trust

    When trust breaks down between teachers and leaders retention becomes the first thing to suffer.
  • A clear view of every evaluation

    A clear view of every evaluation

    Fix it before anything is final.

  • See what's backing the rating

    View the evidence tied to every rating. Understand what is actually supporting the decision not just what was recorded.

  • See what's missing

    Instantly identify gaps in evidence before a rating is finalized. Know exactly where more attention is needed.

  • See where things don't line up

    Catch inconsistencies between evaluators early. Bring everyone onto the same page before submission.

  • What this gives you

    Built for decisions that matter

    Leaders can stand behind their decisions and teachers understand them.

  • 50%

    More Evidence

    More rubric-aligned evidence
  • 3x

    Faster decisions

    Form evidence to rating
  • +25%

    Complete Instruction 

    More observable instructional evidence
    captured during walkthroughs
  • Transparency

    Clear evaluation

    Every rating is transparent what supports it, what doesn’t, what needs attention before anything is final.

    Consistency

    Fair decisions

    Reduce variation across evaluators. Same evidence always leads to the same rating.

    Trust

    Defensible ratings

    Leaders can stand behind every decision. Teachers understand what matters and why.

    Strong Evaluations Build Strong Cultures

    When evaluations are clear and supported, people work differently

    Teachers are part of the process, not just the outcome. That builds trust and keeps strong teachers in your schools.

    Leaders can explain decisions.

    Teachers know what matters.

    Conversations are direct and useful.

    Teachers are part of the process, not just the outcome.

    are your ratings actually supported ?

    The One-Hour Calibration Snapshot

    A quick way to see how your current evaluations hold up using the evidence you already have. Just a clear view of what's solid, what may be at risk, and what to strengthen before you finalize.

    How it works

    Not a free trial. It's better. 

    You see what is at risk before it becomes a problem.

    Before the session (Lite Prep)

    Each principal selects 1-3 teachers and brings the evidence they already have.

    Observation notes

    Lesson plans

    Student work

    Reflections

    During the live session

    Upload your evidence and see how it aligns to your rubric

    Compare your ratings to RefynED, your neutral evaluation partner

    What you see instantly

    Where your ratings align and where they differ

    Where evidence is thin, missing, or not fully aligned

    Which ratings are well supported and which may not hold up

    What to strengthen before you finalize

    Why it matters

    Know where your evaluations hold up before they're final

    It’s about knowing where your evaluations hold up and where they don’t before they’re final so you can address gaps, strengthen ratings, and act with certainty.

    Learn more here

    START SMALL

    Ratings now affect pay in a bigger way

    With TIA, small inconsistencies can impact compensation, making clarity and consistency more important than ever.